Phoenix
Director: Christian Petzold
Length: 94 mins
It’s June
1945, the end of the war. Auschwitz survivor Nelly (Nina Hoss) returns to
Berlin to look for her husband Johnny (Ronald Zehrfeld) who believes his wife
to be dead, and is after her inheritance. Here’s the twist: Nelly has suffered
a facial injury and has undergone reconstructive surgery, such that she looks
pretty good, but not enough for Johnny to recognise her. He suggests Nelly
pretend to be his dead wife (well, she is!!) and they can go after the money.
Hoss and Zehrfeld play their roles well, and the film looks fabulous. It has in
fact won a heap of awards but for me there are fatal flaws in the plot that
render the whole thing unbelievable.
Maybe worth a look!
For a full review from Chris Thompson (with whom I totally agree):
http://www.cinephilia.net.au/show_review.php?movieid=5924Maybe worth a look!
For a full review from Chris Thompson (with whom I totally agree):
By the Sea
Director: Angelina Jolie Pitt
Length: 132 mins
This is a
tricky one to review. It could cynically be seen as a vehicle for the star
couple – a million miles away from the action of Mr and Mrs Smith,
but something emulating the style of 1950s European arthouse cinema, all moody
looks, artfully framed shots, long silences, and plenty of marital angst.
Ex-dancer Vanessa and writer Roland head to a French coastal village to try to
revive their flagging marriage. It’s obvious something is seriously wrong, and
Vanessa won’t let Roland near her. We constantly get moments of insight into
Vanessa’s disturbed brain, but what she is remembering we only discover near
the film’s conclusion. Things spark up when the couple meet Lea and Francois, a
honeymooning pair in the adjoining villa, whom Vanessa and Roland take to observing
through a spyhole in the wall. This film is erotic, stylised, self-conscious in
parts, but something about it succeeds, and a welcome addition is Neils
Arestrup as Michel, the local bar owner.
Worth a look!
For a full review from Bernard Hemingway:
I thought Phoenix was a lot better than that and engrossed myself in the study of what Germany and all its inhabitants were like directly after the war. On this level, it totally worked for me.
ReplyDeleteBy the sea .. well that was something else! great scenery and photography but the characters and storyline left me cold! I simply didn't care two hoots about them at all!
Thanks for these responses Roberto. I love that we all see the films differently and I think everyone's view is valid!
ReplyDelete